Best Keyboard Layouts Compared: QWERTY vs Dvorak vs Colemak vs Workman
An in-depth comparison of the major keyboard layouts. Learn the advantages and disadvantages of QWERTY, Dvorak, Colemak, and Workman to decide which layout is right for your typing needs.
The Dominance of QWERTY
The QWERTY layout, invented in 1873 by Christopher Sholes, was designed to prevent mechanical typewriter jams by placing common letter pairs apart. Despite the original mechanical limitations being obsolete, QWERTY remains the global standard due to network effects — everyone learns it, all keyboards ship with it, and the ecosystem is fully optimized around it. The major disadvantage is that many common letter combinations require awkward finger movements, potentially limiting top speed.
Dvorak: Efficiency by Design
The Dvorak Simplified Keyboard, patented in 1936 by August Dvorak, was designed for maximum efficiency. It places the most common letters on the home row, with 70% of keystrokes occurring on the home row versus 32% for QWERTY. Typists also alternate hands more frequently, theoretically enabling faster typing. Despite scientific evidence showing efficiency gains of 30-40%, Dvorak never achieved widespread adoption due to the dominance of QWERTY and retraining costs.
Colemak: The Modern Compromise
Colemak, created in 2006 by Shai Coleman, is designed to be easier to learn from QWERTY while providing most of Dvorak's efficiency benefits. Only 17 keys change position from QWERTY, compared to Dvorak's complete rearrangement. Colemak keeps common shortcuts (Ctrl+C, Ctrl+V, Ctrl+Z) in their QWERTY positions. The layout places 74% of keystrokes on the home row and emphasizes finger rolling for common bigrams.
Workman and Other Alternatives
Workman is a newer layout designed specifically to reduce awkward finger movements that exist even in Colemak and Dvorak. It prioritizes inward rolls over outward rolls and minimizes same-finger bigrams. Other notable layouts include Norman, QWPR, and MTGAP (Model-based Typing Grammar Approach). While these layouts offer theoretical advantages, their tiny user bases mean poor OS support and minimal learning resources.
The Cost of Switching Layouts
Switching keyboard layouts requires significant time investment — typically 3-6 months to reach your original QWERTY speed. During the transition period, your productivity will drop substantially. The decision should be based on your typing needs: professional typists and writers may benefit most, while casual users may not find the investment worthwhile. Most layout enthusiasts recommend Colemak as the best balance of improvement and learnability.
Testing Different Layouts on CheetahType
CheetahType supports typing tests across all major keyboard layouts. Use the settings panel to switch layouts and take comparative tests. The platform tracks your performance independently for each layout, allowing you to measure your improvement during the transition period. Test with the 60-second mode for accurate speed and accuracy measurements across different layouts.